Will India attack Pakistan?

Question

Will India attack Pakistan?

Answer 1

No. The Pakistani government has condemned the attacks and will disavow the militants. The Pakistani government has no effective control over much of the country, which is in the hands of tribes loyal to the Taliban and Al Qaeda. Knocking out the weak Pakistani central government does not solve the problem. The tribal territories in Northwest Pakistan have become what Afghanistan was 7 years ago, the terrorist hatchery of the world. The solution is going to have to be an artful combination of politics, money and military might. Right now the Pakistani government is not willing to do any aspect of that and has effectively ceded control over those areas to the indigenous tribes.

Answer 2

Terrorism is an industry in Pakistan and it has US as its ally(lobbyist in the US).. Hence US presents Nelson's eye on this score.



However, India was never an aggressor and hence it would not attack Pak.



Things will improve only when US and its allies change their stance.

Answer 3

Pakistan will have to bring the people responsible to justice or it will find itself at war.



Pakistan will likely break up into pieces first.



Waziristan Kashmir Balochistan Punjab and Sindh. Then there will be civil wars and wars between the *stans.



India won't know who to attack.

Answer 4

its not a point of provocation and countering it...v have a serious issue on hands....I doubt Pakistan needs India to attack it in the context of latest developments...the country of Pakistan is to a brink of collapse..its economy is non existent...the situation of law and order is known to the entire civilized world...its time for the incompetent Pakistani government to realise this and let the civilised world help Pakistan out of this situation...its a breeding ground of extremism and intolerance....there seems to be a lack of progressive attitude in the society there...Indian government shud be called in to help pakistan fix the issues leading to such hatred...Im an Indian and i think every Pakistani is an INDIAN first...the Islam isnt about hatred and no religion of the world preaches violence...so i wish v as people of south asia the Indian subcontinent shud build a force to tackle extremism and adopt laws collectively to bring peace and brotherhood amongst al of south asians...

Answer 5

Hmmm Damn Our Generation is at worst!!!! We should be moving toward peace not wars... "War On Terror" think ...... To become the powerful country you need to control drug trade... Controlling Afghanistan will make one country rich, powerful!! Russia failed because US did not want Russia to control the Drug trade.. Now look "War on Terror" US trying to control Afghanistan and Saudi makes it hard to get oil.. look US is in "Iraq" ... to Control Iraq for oil and Afghanistan for drug trade both attempts failed and thousands of people are dead.... My point is since all the people here wants India to attack Pakistan...... Are Nuclear Weapons will be used ??? Oh come on people you can tell each other "Oh I wont use it" but eventually in war either you win what it takes or you die.... So since everyone made a conclusion Pakistan will be destroyed...etc So my question is Who will take over Pakistan after the invasion ? hmm India will.... now my question is now India has majority of 40 million Muslims (Pakistanis) Hmmm Im Western Damn I see India is hosting Terrorists!!!!!! You can destroy a country to pieces but your internal problems will never go away!!! It takes afew mins to kill millions of people in war Technology has advanced far more than WWII... You CAN BE THE VICTIM!!!



Yeah Yeah... You can argue US went to Iraq for WMD and Afghanistan to kill terrorist..... Look at the Big Picture!!! Natural Resources and you have to ask the question,,, "Whats in-it for me?"

Answer 6

I think its very irresponsible of Indian politicians and media to point fingers at Pakistan without any solid proof. The attackers themselves claimed to be from Hyderabad Deccan. It would be a big mistake to attack pakistan because this is a war no one will win. Both countries have nuclear weapons and we can well imagine the consequences.

Answer 7

pakistan is a atomic power and no body can not hit easily.It is not a word war but at relate with the life of the two nations.From my point of view the friendship of pakistan and india can not break up.

Answer 8

why the hell india would attack pakistan...what sense does that make...even if they were pakistanis .. what control their govt can have over it...they are bombing their own pakistan....so india is no big deal for them...do u guys have any idea..what goes into a war....people die...oh sorry..how would u guys know...bloody keyboard warriors...ever got hit with a bullet...n u guys have the guts talk about war....innocent people died in mumbai....in islamabad..lahore..delhi...what did u guys do about it ??????????????? think about it n then write crap.....

Answer 9

rehan, india has whooped pakistan's *** three times u tried to attack. and dude if it wasn't for international pressures, india can destroy pakistan in a single night.

Answer 10

I suspect that those that planned, funded and recruited those that carried out the attacks in Mumbai are certainly trying to initiate such a reaction!

Answer 11

this question has some of the best and most knowledgeable answers i've seen in the past two days (at least the first 3 lol) instead of the usual totally uneducated bashing that goes on, so that's refreshing. also good question



as for the answer, i don't think that this is nearly enough to attack pakistan, unless it is proven that the pak government is directly involved and the us and other countries back this up; which is not likely to happen, even though it is likely that they were involved in some shape or form



edit: to ruby, indian organized crime is closely linked with pakistan, e.g. dawood ibrahim

Answer 12

India-Pakistan intelligence chiefs talking at length on hotline followed by Defence Ministerial level talks and then a 6 am emergency cabinet meeting all point to one direction. My own feeling is that the Pak govt is completely held ransom by the terrorists who have a safe home in Pakistan. India should start commando operations into Pakistan just like the Americans are doing and flush out the lairs of the terrorists. If India invades Pakistan at this time, it will have the world leaders backing it. Pakistan at this time is on it's knees and can't afford a war spanning more than 5 days. This is the time to strike and wipe out the incapable government there. Thereafter, the Indian Government should provide protection to the Pakistani citizens who have none from their own government. Pakistan citizens are our brothers and have a right to live a secure and prosperous lives. But Pakistan as a nation should be wiped out and be made a part of India where all would find a tolerant home.

Answer 13

Ok guys, think about it for a second. How many countries are fighting in Afghanistan against Taliban( who don't have anything)? The answer is many, and look whats happening there. British generals are saying that they have no control there. Israel attacked Lebanon but could not advance, so unless all of you think that Pakistan is weaker than Taliban and Lebanon then sure India will attack Pakistan but if not then i don't think it would be feasible for both countries to fight since both are nuclear powers and if they happen to engage in nuclear fight it will be disastrous for both countries. Now Pakistan can not sustain a fight along its long border with India and that would likely be the cause of nuclear war between both countries because Pakistan's last option would be to use its nuclear arsenal. So the conclusion : No war

Answer 14

There are two possible Conspiracy Theories



1- India will remain quite and try to maintain peace. In such bad economic time the affordability of a war could be a huge problem. If Decision is made inside India without Foreign Interference than there will be no war.



2- If india is getting America Support and Advise, it may well attack pakistan. As Pkaistan is in Worst of times (financial Crises, Electric Crises, Housing Crises, Water Crises, Gas Crises, Full Of Corruption). Terrorism Crises is the major one. Pakistan dont want America to come in and America wants to come in so itll want to engage pakistan with india and will come in from the Afghanistan side. India also knows a good time when pakistan is engaged in a problem with afghanistan border. May want the control of pakistan. Pakistan will be fooish if they dont Make good arrangement to Finish all the crises going on inside the country. Reduce Chances of Foreigners Attacking in pakistan. No Electricity , No Gas How they think they are going to fight. Its not simple as playing Kabadi. Zardari and Nawaz Shareef have Already Finished Half of Pakistan in less than a Year. Such Bad Economy means theve ate > half of pakistan.

Answer 15

You can never trust Pakistan! i am a pakistani and we have not taken 1 step forward towards progress and success for the country in 60 plus years were as India has flurished in everything.

I believe a country like pakistan with so much of corruption and poverty and no direction and leadership, and just being stupid, people like this want everybody to be miserable and join their pity party. If they are not sucessfull we make sure no one else will be either. The only way these people know to get attention its by fear, killing innocent people.

So do i think pakistan should be attacked, HELL YEA! i know Rehan you thinking what the F&^%$ . Rehan calm down you big pakistani you..LOLOL you know damn what pakistan is capable of ....Not a damn thing.

Answer 16

Investigations??? that is such a coward and ignorant word some of my friends are using. the investigations are still on for the blasts which happened in Delhi in 2005 or what happened in jaipur some time ago(its been decades of investigations). The whole world knows that pakistan is a terror factory.By the pure common sense an enemy should be attacked at its weakest and this is the time they are in bad shape with the forex reserve drying out n they are still struggling to have a proper democracy. This is the write time if not to completely resolve the problem as some of my friends pointed out at the possibility of a civil war in pakistan and why don't we act as a catalyst in doing so. aren't we facing a civil war from decades in one or the other form in Punjab or kashmir.

If we cant force pakistan to stop doing this to us than lets just help them getting into a civil war or economic breakdown so they have enough problems to deal with and we can rest in peace at least for some time.

Answer 17

1. It is not in India's policy to attack another country.

2. India will do anything and everything to defend itself - even if it means retaliation and war.

3. Before reaching a conclusion on whether India should attack Pakistan, we whould first establish direct link of these events with Pakistani government, because Pakistan is not able to control its extremist and terrorist groups within Pakistan.



All said and done, some action is to be taken for the incidences that took place SOON - whether that action is against a country or some group or some individuals is a matter of investigation.



The action is necesary to set an example that these deplorable incidences will not be tolerated.

Answer 18

Chill out and wait for the investigation. It has only just begun.



We have to stop falling for the media propaganda. The globalist controlled media and globalist controlled government have an interest in keeping us afraid of muslims extremists. It helps them justify the war agenda and the continued gradual dismantling of the Constitution.



If you want some truth, read from independent media. Independent media is not instant - it takes a few days for the stories to come up. They don't have the same resources as the globalist stooges.



Evidence has already surfaced suggesting this may be the work of Indian organized crime. I doubt you will hear the media run with that. C'mon .. you cannot expect them to miss the opportunity to promote the new world order by actually telling the truth for a change, can you?

Answer 19

Hey REHAN India's might and power was shown when Bangladesh was created and after each time you attacked us we won and you talk about the underworld you guys in Pakistan were the creators for that so before you comment check your history and about Kashmir you people are like dogs want to run behind the car and bark but when time of confrontation approaches in a face to face situation you run like bitches.

Answer 20

Yea......they will with the help of other countries too......many of the ministers for the 1st time are actually blaming pakistan on live tv.....n still the pak home minister denies its involvement evn after so much proof(sea links, seized mobiles, questioning captured terrorists,etc )....this is going to be a turning pt......the terrorists r pakistanis n came to mumbai via sea from karachi switching from trawlers to boats.....sum boats were even seized and a mobile ws found frm which 5 calls were made 2 karachi before the attack and 3 after......so i am sure india n countries like us n uk will do this........

.....nwz now.....just praying for my city.... :(

Answer 21

Yes, India will act with US assistance and support. Hopefully the Pakistan government will stand down limiting fight to terrorists vs. India and US.



Problem is Pakistan houses terrorists Pakistan government does not control nor do they seem to WANT to control. No doubt Bin Laden is in Pakistan if alive.



India is tired of Pakistan based terrorist acts. India people want action. No more talking with Pakistan. Its not about Pakistan government, its about getting the terrorists living IN Pakistan.

Answer 22

No any Pakistani is responsible, To attack to Mumbai. I thnk India have already Big power Force, an Pakistani people is not responsible... Its responsible only India Forces, an Police..... Haider from India

Answer 23

India should attack Pakistan. It should make its reponse loud and unmistakeable. It should kill as many insurgent leaders as possible within Pakistan.

Answer 24

Why should India attack pakistan, when pakis are digging their own grave themselves. Just wait for another 10 years and these stupid jihadi groups will kill each other.



If India attack Pakistan, It will be like a flourishing rich person stopping down to coming out of car and figthing with a downtrodden beggar who anyway has no future. So let these beggar die of its own diseases and hunger rather than we dirtying our hands and sullying our own history. India is great nations, where does pakistan stand in world'eyes. People secretly mumbles horrible thing as soon as someone brings out their pakistani passport... They had dug their own graves.. Dont worry, these jihad will wipe their own *** from this earth soon.



Just be strong as ever and defend yourself. World envies successful, prosperous and progressing nation like ours. We cannt stoop down to tackle barking dogs like Pakistan. Apart from terrorsim tell me one great thing world knows muslims for? Indians are known for their tolerance, culture, resilience , brilliance and what not.. And Muslims... just for producing countless kids who eventually turn up as terrorists.

And funniest thing is , they chose an insane person as their president (that stupid Zardari, who rode on shoulders of his wife to reach where he is...what kindda a man is that) If you pakistani dont know , please check that Your current president came out of corruption cases in britain claiming dementia. Ha ha.. A mad man for president.. What say? what will happen to counrty whose president claimed to be mad just to get rid of corruption scandal.. You guys so deserve this prez.. check this out , if you dont believe it.





http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/7c186d52-72f0-11dd-983b-0000779fd18c,s01=1.html?nclick_check=&nclick_check=1



ria

Answer 25

bangladesh is weak so is pakistan. china's the only problem.

Answer 26

probably and they should

Answer 27

THEY BETTER