Question:
Why do people separate egypt from africa. like it's not a country in africa?
Norman
2017-01-14 14:58:16 UTC
It is known that the cradle of civilization is africa.... In africa there are counties like zimbabwe, the congo, nigeria...... And egypt.. But when ever eygpt is spoken of it's as if to say it's a country by it's self not in africa. When movies concerning or surrounding it's areas in eygpt are played. The actors are always white. Ironically though the pharoes are white and their servants black...... In other countries where caucasians originate if there are movies where they are they are played by actors who look like them..... That in it's self is racist. What's also racist is the fact that alexander though he reigned in eygpt did so at the end of the height of the empire, and yet it's viewed as if to say it's always been that way. Astrologist in the past were prominently white. And during their studies and findings made racist remarks throughout african egypt. Saying that africans could not have built this, wrote that. Later when the finding turn out to be that in fact africans did do these great works the only way you'll find that information is if you hunt for it. Whereas the lie is still prominent...... Egypt is in africa.... The egyptians are african. The invaders however are not. So is it intellectual to teach the world that the was to be original is to steal from the original. Kill any who may prove you to be a fake. And teach the world to do the same..... Smh p.s please if your gonna answer my question keep your emotions out of it. Only valid factual info please. Thx.
Six answers:
Curtis
2017-01-18 21:34:13 UTC
This attitude is widespread among Europeans, the descendants of European slavers and colonialists, in particular. There are also Arabs who feel the same about Egypt not being an African country.



History is written by winners and rewritten by conquerors. Sooner or later, there is power-shift. Power changes hands, colors and forms. Power has changed hands, colors and forms many times in world history.



Europeans managed to colonize Africa and enslave millions of Africans. Arabs managed to colonize Africa and enslave millions of Africans



Europeans will never admit that a long time ago before Europe achieved dominance, ancient Egyptians contributed to the Greek civilization, they will never admit that millions of Europeans were enslaved in Africa, they will never admit that dark skinned Egyptians are the oldest stock of Egyptians.



Arabs will rarely admit that a long time before the Arabs achieved dominance over Africans, the Arabic peninsula was part of the Ethiopian Empire. Ethiopians conquered and occupied Arab lands for hundreds of years.



This is an answer given by an Egyptian about the "race" of ancient Egyptians and the Africaness of Egyptians. This is the best answer ever from someone from Egypt



Egyptians are definitely not Arabs, nor considered themselves Arabs prior to the overthrow of Farouk by Nasser. Well before the Nasserite years Egyptians under the leadership of Sheikh Tantawi and Saad Zaghul considered themselves ''just Egyptians'' but because of Pan-Arabism have embraced Arabs.



Another shock to people is that Arabs invaded the land of Egypt in 640 AD and the later Arabian Caliphates forced jizya tax and land tax upon the real descendants of the ancient Egyptians which were poor peasant farmers in the countryside. Neither Arabs nor any invaders bothered to mix with these people,



SO THE ANCIENT EGYPTIAN RACE LIVES ON WITH THE RURAL FELLAHIN AND SA3EADI PEOPLE IN UPPER EGYPT.



Foreigners like Americans and Europeans also have an eschewed sense of Egyptian phenotype due to the less migration of more elite Egyptians compared to more poor Egyptians who have a more African phenotype. This accounts for confusing remarks made about the ethnicity of the modern and ancient Egyptians.



So here are some generally terms for Egypt and Egyptians:



a) Sa3eadi people: Generally less mixed than Cairene or Bohary Egyptians. Generally these people possess more phenotypes closer to Africans. Although some in Middle Egypt are more mixed, and the further south you go into Egypt particularly around Luxor/Aswan the darker the people become and more African features.



b) Balady: Typically rural Egyptians from the Delta and Upper Egypt that have recently moved into the Egyptian city. Many of these people are confined to urban slums very comparable to ghettoes in America and Europe. Typically more ''mulatto'' in appearance than the typical Egyptian. Elite or sell out Egyptians look down upon them as stupid and dirty.



c) Bohary: Typically a term for a person from Lower Egypt or the Delta. Although this region is not devoid of Africoid people, the majority looks more Mediterranean, but occasionally there is a deviation within the population. Some even look like lighter skinned African Americans. Some mixing with Arabs has occurred, and prior to this some mixture with Semites via Palestine.



d) Fellahin: refers generally to farmers in the Delta but also includes farming communities from Beni Suef to Suhaj in Middle Egypt. Generally purer than the city dwellers in Egypt. Both Christians and Muslim populations are identical in appearance.



Let me also say that there is historical documentation of intermingling with Greeks, Jews and Syrian populations from Greco-Roman times down to Christian times in Egypt. Some areas in the north like Alexandria had larger populations than the indigenous Egyptian populations, and so you can tell that northern Egyptians probably absorbed lots of foreign admixture.
?
2017-01-14 19:10:41 UTC
It's all a thing about Geography v Culture. It's not deliberately racist. Geographically Egypt is of course in Africa (it's the last country in the NE African corner). BUT culturally and in terms of majority ethic and racial group it's always been part of the Mideast and Mediterranean, those cultures, those civilizations. The rest of Africa was up the Nile and on the other side of the Sahara (although there was some mixing).

Today Egyptians consider themselves very much to be 'Arabs' and of course Muslims attached to the rest of the Arabic Middle East. They do not consider themselves to be Africans although technically their country is in Africa.

In other words culture, history, ethnic, racial group wins out over geography.
2017-01-14 17:25:05 UTC
Egypt is the Cradle of Civilization. Arabic is in the Afroasiatic Language Family. Arabic is very similar to Hausa and Somali. Persian is not an Afroasiatic Language. Arabs led by ‘Amr ibn al-‘As mixed with the Africans (Blacks). Egyptians are mostly mixed with Sudanese, who are Arabic-Speaking Africans (Blacks). Please don't mention China or Japan as they are racist and not the Cradle of Civilization.
2017-01-14 15:29:58 UTC
Because they're not a typical African Country, their language isn't similar, their ethnicity isn't similar, their culture isn't similar, they're objectively not African, eventhough the Country is located in Africa.
2017-01-14 15:25:17 UTC
Egypt is in North Africa where the people look different to those further South,anyway if we all come from the blacks then why is most of Africa so primitive.? China and Japan dont accept the "cradle of civilization political nonsense,and neither do I
2017-01-14 15:17:02 UTC
Ancient Egypt was a Mediterranean culture and not representative of Sub-Saharan African culture.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...