Question:
Should Saddam be hanged if it means endless jihad against America?
anonymous
2006-10-05 22:26:43 UTC
Should Saddam be hanged if it means endless jihad against America?
Sixteen answers:
anonymous
2006-10-06 06:05:42 UTC
No Saddam Hussein should not be hanged. Absolutely not nor should he be executed in any way.



Whether or not this hanging would result in a jihad (endless or not) is really not the issue. We should not decide whether to punish someone/anyone on the basis of what it might cost us or others.

If we did then the Mafia would never be brought to court.

No.

For me the issue is an important one - of principle, and perhaps difficult for some to handle comfortably, especially those who watch Fox "News" (sic). There is a mentality of black and white which is not helpful post war.



You see, the level of violence in Iraq is higher now than when Saddam was in power even counting the deaths of the CIA -funded Kurds killed with Western supplied chemical weapons.



The point is that the whole trial process is flawed and political - how could it be otherwise? Winners decide the rules. Imagine George Bush being captured en route somewhere in the East (middle or not) and put on trial for the illegal war and the deaths of 30,000 civilians in Iraq bombed during the invasion for "liberation". Think about that.



Recently, the new "government" of Iraq has voted on a number of issues and it showed a remarkably pro-US posture. That will have further enflamed many Iraqis (rather like having the last Emperor of China being a puppet of the Japanese). This is why the place is in chaos, and at risk of being Balkanised. There can be no peace until the last US soldier leaves and then there will be darkness before the dawn for sure!!

No, this is a sensitive and political trial and as such it is better to imprison the man if found guilty by his peers.

When the Iraqis finally get the government they deserve, then decisions can be made. While the US holds the keys to power (notionally and tenuously) it would be well to incarcerate the man.

Incidentally, as we well are aware, there are US soldiers who have murdered and they will not receive the death penalty in the US for sure. We need to act with justice in another land.
Toaster o' Death
2006-10-05 22:49:37 UTC
good question... well, saddam has lost his honor and authorithy, just by getting caught... so he is like a little insignificant bug...

but, hey, people, we're talking about America here... can't america defend itself from these scums?! america should hang saddam, just to show others that they won this fight, and they will also win the war, to gaing honor...

if bush really gets pissed of, he can launch 20 nuclear bombs on the whole Asian continent and finish this stupid war... but then it's always the problem about civilians... they will die in a way or another sooner or later... but then the whole american people will jump at bush's head... how can america win all the wars, if the people do not support their country...
anonymous
2006-10-05 22:38:19 UTC
Endless jihad has already been proclaimed against America and all of Western civilization. Hanging that SOB won't change anything.
AlfRed E nEuMaN 4 preSIDent
2006-10-05 22:42:18 UTC
Saddam is the main reason why there's hardly any jihad in Iraq in the first place. he's a dictator but he's no hardline extremist. no true blood religious fanatic would even shed a drop of blood for him. that is what that is so wrong about the war in Iraq .......... this is not a war on terror ........... it became a recruitment ground for terrorists only after the us invasion that remove him from power.
Andrew D
2006-10-05 22:36:40 UTC
Saddam has nothing to do with jihad, you loser. Try to educate yourself before asking stupid questions. And don't watch FOX.
MintyFresh
2006-10-05 22:29:52 UTC
i think we should hand him over to the Kawaities (or however you spell it)

because they would give him what he deserves.

and america wouldnt have hung him and wouldnt of caused as many problems...heh.



americas a little messed up.

i try not to think about saddam on top of all of this chaos... but yeah good question.



many hearts and much love

~Nicole
anonymous
2006-10-05 22:41:04 UTC
You ever read about the Crusades in the Middle ages and what was accomplished by Christians and Jews? Ever wonder who would be

annialated should a " Crusade" begin again.
?
2016-10-16 01:36:19 UTC
i'm so happy which you introduced this up. i will use your words, "Anwar al-Awlaki and Samir Khan declared conflict against usa. the two considered one of them have been al Qaeda. the two considered one of them actively participated jihad against usa. the two considered one of them have been kill in Yemen jointly as travelling with an al Qaeda bomb maker." they could have been killed. the subject is a few human beings have self belief that they could have won their Constitutional rights to Due technique. So here is the component, I have not any concern with getting rid of individuals who've renounced their citizenship, left the country and declared conflict on the U. S.. in the event that they do it jointly as in yet another us of a, Kill em, they do no longer seem to be voters anymore. in the event that they stay here and declare conflict in this us of a they have a appropriate to Due technique.
anonymous
2006-10-05 22:41:20 UTC
He won't be hung in America. There will definitely be chaos in whatever country they hang him in. but I think homeland security will keep to a minimum the wave effect here.
LadyRebecca
2006-10-05 22:28:57 UTC
Hang or not hang, that will happen regardless for the US and the rest of the western world.



Sad but true
Ivan
2006-10-05 22:29:55 UTC
I don't think hanging Saddam will create such a big ruckus. He was not that popular among his own...
Alex
2006-10-05 22:50:23 UTC
He just needs to be in a real secure and bad prison for the rest of his life.
Plasmapuppy
2006-10-05 22:28:45 UTC
endless jihad is what we currently have so sure, why not?
Steve B
2006-10-05 22:37:52 UTC
yes
acid tongue
2006-10-05 23:04:12 UTC
that's up to the Iraqis, they are trying him not us, we just turned him over
angelino911
2006-10-05 22:35:31 UTC
if you hung him, you will hang many american soldiers in iraq.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...